Anybody who has read this blog at all, will realise that I am quite a fan of Microsoft’s Windows Home Server, (WHS), software, and pretty much have used it since its inception.
There has been a little bit of a buzz about the product in the last year or so, ever since Microsoft announced that there was going to be version 2 of the product based on the Windows Server 2008 R2 code. This is currently known to the world as “Vail”. Not only did this mean that the product would be based on contemporary code, (which is also shared with Windows 7), but it also meant that most of the features that we have grown to love in the first version of the product, were likely to be enhanced and extended.
The one thing that WHS users were not expecting, was to lose a feature and a major one at that. Not to go over old ground, but one of the interesting features of WHS was its ability to look at a group of hard disks, and allow the user to see them as just one. Not only that, but if you selected to duplicate certain folders, then the content of those folders would be duplicated across multiple disks. How much work did a user had to put into using these capabilities? None! That’s why everybody loved it.
However in a blog post released yesterday, Microsoft announced that this feature would be dropped from WHS version 2. Why? Well, they say it’s because most people put terabyte and larger disks into their WHS machines these days, and therefore there is no need to combine multiple smaller discs with the disk extender feature. But by dropping this “merge” capability, what they also remove from the product is the capability to do the on-the-fly disk and folder duplication.I think that the real reason it was dropped, it is more about their capability to make it work reliably, however we will probably never know for sure.
This seems to have been a universal outcry from the WHS community, is this likely to change Microsoft’s mind? Unlikely I would think, but I’d like to hope that Microsoft listened to their users and contemplate reintroducing this technology. After all it’s part of the reason that made WHS the fantastic tool that most found it to be.
Am I likely to upgrade to Vail now? My gut reaction now is no, however WHS does lots of other things including automatic backups of the connected PCs every night, and there is a wide array of add-ins written by an enthusiastic user community, that extends the functionality of the base product. It may be that one of these add-ins, replaces some of the disk duplication features of the original product, who knows? So really it’s a case of watch this space, Microsoft may yet move on their position, or there may be a developer out there who has already started the coding of an add-in that will placate us all…
Recent Comments